Roofer working in special protective work wear gloves, using air or pneumatic nail gun installing concrete or CPAC cement roofing tiles on top of the new roof under construction residential building

Debunking Roof Myths: 6 Costly Mistakes Twin Cities Homeowners Keep Making

Let’s face it, owning a home in the Twin Cities means your roof takes a beating—between the blizzards in winter and the humid heat in summer, it’s a lot to handle.

But here’s the kicker: many homeowners still fall for roofing myths that could leave their wallets as battered as their shingles.

This article is here to clear the air.

We’ll tackle some of the most common misconceptions, from DIY fixes to ignoring those “small leaks” you think aren’t a big deal.

By the end, you’ll be armed with the knowledge to keep your roof in shape and avoid expensive, unnecessary repairs.

Ready to save your roof—and your bank account? Let’s get started.

Key Takeaways

  • Ignoring roof inspections means small issues can become big, expensive problems—don’t wait until you see damage.
  • Roofing materials vary in durability—picking the wrong one for Minnesota’s weather can lead to more repairs.
  • Adding extra shingles sounds easy, but it traps moisture and can cause hidden damage and structural problems.
  • Hiring the cheapest roofer often leads to low-quality work, costing you more in the long run.

6 Costly Roofing Myths Twin Cities Homeowners Need to Stop Believing

Myth #1: “I Don’t Need to Worry About My Roof Until I See Damage”

Waiting until you see the damage is like ignoring your car’s check engine light—it’s not going to end well. Just because your roof looks fine doesn’t mean it’s not quietly falling apart.

Twin Cities weather is tough on roofs, and neglecting regular maintenance can lead to big problems like leaks, mold, and even structural damage.

Instead of waiting for disaster, make annual inspections a habit. During your quick roof check-up, keep an eye out for these common signs of potential trouble:

  • Cracked or curling shingles
  • Loose or damaged flashing
  • Moss or algae growth
  • Changes in shingle color
  • Missing granules on shingles
  • Water stains on ceilings or walls inside your home

Myth #2: “All Roofing Materials Are the Same”

Spoiler: They’re not.

Roofing materials can make or break your home, especially with the Twin Cities’ crazy weather. Some roofs can handle the snow and ice better than others, and choosing the wrong material could mean more repairs.

Asphalt shingles are popular, but not all types are created equal. There are two main types:

  1. 3-tab shingles are more affordable, but they’re thinner and less durable. They can struggle with the harsh winters and heavy snow, making them more prone to damage over time.
  2. Architectural shingles are thicker and more durable, offering better protection from snow, ice, and high winds. While they cost more upfront, they last longer and provide better long-term value.

Metal roofs last longer and handle snow well, but they can be pricier upfront.

Clay tiles? Pretty, but not the best for snow-heavy winters.

Picking the right material is all about balancing durability, cost, and how well it can stand up to Minnesota’s freezing winters and humid summers.

Myth #3: “I Can Just Add Another Layer of Shingles”

Adding another layer of shingles sounds easy, right? Just pile them on and call it a day. But it’s not that simple.

Layering shingles can trap moisture, cause structural headaches, and void your roof’s warranty. It’s like putting on two coats because you’re cold—it feels good at first, but soon you’re sweating under all that extra weight.

The better option? Strip it down to one solid layer. Less is definitely more when it comes to shingles. A lighter roof means fewer long-term issues and more money saved.

Here’s why piling on more shingles isn’t the shortcut it seems:

  1. Excessive weight can damage your roof structure.
  2. Hidden damage stays hidden until it’s too late.
  3. Moisture gets trapped between layers, leading to leaks.
  4. You’ll end up paying more to fix multiple layers later on.

Myth #4: “Roofing Is a DIY Job”

Sure, you’ve watched a few DIY roof care videos and fixed that leaky faucet last month. But roofing? It’s not as easy as it looks.

Roofing is dangerous, and improper installation can lead to even bigger problems. Plus, no one wants to take a tumble off a ladder.

Leave it to the pros. They know how to install a roof properly, protect warranties, and spot hidden damage you might miss. In the long run, it’s cheaper—and much safer.

So, if you’re facing any of these situations, it’s time to put down the DIY tools and call in a professional:

  • Significant roof damage
  • Older roofs needing full replacement
  • After a storm with high winds or hail
  • If your roof warranty is at risk
  • Anytime you’re unsure what you’re dealing with

Myth #5: “Gutters Don’t Matter That Much”

Gutters are more than just a minor detail. They’re like your home’s defense against water damage.

In the Twin Cities, with heavy rains and snowmelt, gutters play a key role in keeping your roof and foundation safe. Clogged gutters can lead to leaks, mold, and even damage your siding. Ignoring them could mean paying for more than just a roof fix later on.

Here are some quick and easy tips to keep your gutters in top shape:

  • Clean gutters twice a year (spring and fall)
  • Install gutter guards to prevent clogs
  • Check for loose or damaged sections after hail or storms
  • Make sure downspouts direct water away from your foundation

Myth #6: “I’ll Save Money by Hiring the Cheapest Roofer”

Bargain hunting for a roofer sounds like a good idea—until your “great deal” turns into a disaster.

Cheap roofers often cut corners with low-quality materials or rush through the job, leaving you with more problems than solutions. And guess who’ll end up paying for that? Yep, you.

Think about it: you wouldn’t pick a brain surgeon based on their discount offer, so why risk it with your roof?

Instead, invest in a reputable roofer.

Do your homework. Here are the key qualities to look for to ensure you’re hiring a reliable professional:

  1. Years of experience in the industry
  2. Proper certifications and licenses
  3. Knowledge of local weather and roofing needs
  4. Strong customer reviews and testimonials
  5. Comprehensive warranties on both materials and labor

Ready to Make Smarter Roofing Decisions? Let Allstar Construction Help

Now that you’ve got the facts, you’re in a much better spot to avoid those costly roofing mistakes. Understanding the truth behind these common myths can help keep your home safe—and your wallet happy. Especially with the wild weather we get in the Twin Cities, it pays to be prepared.

If you’ve got questions or need expert advice, Allstar Construction is here to help. Check out more tips, or contact us anytime. We’re your trusted resource for roofing done right.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Other Blogs

Let’s face it, owning a home in the Twin Cities means your roof takes a beating—between the blizzards in winter and the humid heat in

Winter in the Twin Cities brings snow-covered streets, cozy nights by the fire—and the potential for unexpected roof failures. With freezing temperatures, intense storms, and

If you’ve ever had to file an insurance claim after storm damage, you know it can feel like a mountain of stress and paperwork. Sorting