If you’re replacing your roof in the Twin Cities, choosing the right material is a big decision.
With Minnesota’s heavy snowfall, strong winds, and freeze-thaw cycles, your roof needs to stand up to the elements. While asphalt shingles are the most common choice, metal roofing has been gaining popularity for its durability and longevity.
But which one is right for your home?
Let’s break down seven scenarios where a metal roof is the better choice—and three where asphalt shingles make more sense for Twin Cities homeowners.
Key Takeaways
- Metal roofs handle Minnesota winters better by shedding snow quickly, reducing ice dams, and preventing costly water damage.
- Standing seam metal roofing withstands winds over 140 mph, making it ideal for storm-prone Twin Cities locations.
- Metal roofs can last 50 years or more, suitable if someone plans on staying in their home permanently.
- Fire-resistant metal roofs protect homes near wooded areas against potential lightning strikes and accidental fires better than shingles.
- Asphalt shingles cost less, comply easily with HOA restrictions, and complement traditional home styles better than metal roofing.
7 Scenarios Where a Metal Roof Wins
Minnesota weather is tough on roofs.
Between heavy snow, ice dams, strong winds, and temperature swings, your roof takes a beating year-round. While asphalt shingles are the go-to for many Twin Cities homes, there are times when metal roofing is the smarter choice.
So, when does a metal roof make the most sense?
Here are seven situations where metal wins in the Twin Cities.
1. You Want Maximum Durability Against Harsh Winters
Minnesota winters are no joke.
A metal roof sheds snow easily, preventing ice dams that can cause leaks. Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, can trap snow and ice, leading to costly damage.
If your home is in a snow-heavy area like Stillwater, White Bear Lake, or Edina, it can save you from winter headaches.
2. Your Home Is in a High-Wind Area
Strong winds from summer storms and winter blizzards can rip shingles right off a roof.
In fact, a 2022 storm in Woodbury produced wind gusts exceeding 60 mph, tearing down trees and damaging homes.
Metal roofing, especially standing seam styles, can withstand wind speeds over 140 mph—making it ideal for homes in open areas like Lake Elmo and along the Mississippi River where wind gusts can be intense.
3. You Want a Roof That Lasts 50+ Years
Asphalt shingles typically last 20–30 years, while metal roofs can last 50 years or more with minimal maintenance.
If you’re in your forever home in Minnetonka, Eden Prairie, or along Summit Avenue in St. Paul, investing in metal could mean never replacing your roof again.
4. You’re Concerned About Fire Resistance
Wildfires aren’t a huge risk in the Twin Cities, but lightning strikes and house fires are still a concern. Metal roofs are fire-resistant, while asphalt shingles—especially older ones—can ignite under extreme heat.
If you live near wooded areas like Theodore Wirth Park or along the St. Croix River, this added protection is worth considering.
5. You Want Energy Efficiency in Hot and Cold Weather
Metal roofs reflect heat in the summer and retain warmth in the winter, making them highly energy-efficient. With Twin Cities temperature swings from -20°F to 90°F, this can reduce heating and cooling costs year-round.
Homeowners in Maple Grove, Plymouth, and Eagan looking for lower energy bills might find it to be a smart long-term investment.
6. You Plan to Add Solar Panels
Thinking about solar?
Metal roofs are solar-friendly, as they provide a stable and long-lasting base for solar panel installation. Plus, standing seam metal roofs allow for clamp-on panel mounts, eliminating the need to drill holes that could lead to leaks.
If you’re in progressive, solar-friendly neighborhoods like Northeast Minneapolis or St. Paul’s Mac-Groveland, it is the way to go.
7. You Like a Modern, High-End Aesthetic
If you’re after a sleek, contemporary look—whether for a historic home in Cathedral Hill or a modern build in North Loop—metal roofing provides a distinctive, high-end appearance that asphalt shingles can’t match.
3 Scenarios Where Asphalt Shingles Make More Sense
Metal roofing has plenty of advantages, but it’s not always the best fit for every home. In some cases, asphalt shingles might be the smarter, more practical choice.
Here are three situations where shingles make more sense for Twin Cities homeowners.
1. You’re on a Tight Budget
Metal roofing has higher upfront costs than asphalt shingles.
If you’re planning to stay in your home for only a few years or need an affordable solution, asphalt shingles are the budget-friendly choice.
This makes them ideal for rental properties or starter homes in areas like Brooklyn Park or Bloomington.
2. Your Homeowners Association (HOA) Has Restrictions
Some HOAs and historic districts in the Twin Cities—such as Summit Hill in St. Paul or Linden Hills in Minneapolis—have restrictions on roofing materials. Asphalt shingles are widely accepted, while metal roofing may require special approval.
Always check local guidelines before making a decision.
3. You Prefer a Traditional Look
Metal roofs have a distinct appearance that doesn’t always blend with traditional homes. If you have a classic Tudor in Highland Park or a Craftsman in Nokomis, asphalt shingles might complement your home’s aesthetic better.
Need Help Choosing the Right Roof?
Whether you’re leaning toward the durability of metal roofing or the affordability of asphalt shingles, getting expert advice can make all the difference.
At Allstar Construction, we’ve been helping Twin Cities homeowners make the best roofing choices for decades. Our team knows exactly how Minnesota’s climate affects roofing materials, and we’ll guide you to the best solution for your home and budget.
Call us today at 763-373-1066 for a free estimate!
Let’s find the perfect roofing option for your home.
